Skip to main content

Explainer

What Is Photonic Computing? Light for Logic and Links

Photonic computing uses light, made of particles called photons, in place of electric current for part of the work of a computer. The phrase covers two quite different ideas. One uses light to do calculations. The other uses light to move data between chips. They are at very different stages of maturity, and mixing them up leads to confusion.

Two jobs for light

The first job is computing. Here light passes through a circuit that carries out an operation, usually matrix multiplication, the core arithmetic of AI.

The second job is communication. Here light carries data from one chip to another, replacing electrical wires. The computing itself stays electronic.

The second job is the one reaching products today. The first is mostly in start-up hardware, pilots and research.

Computing with light

Light has a useful property. Waves of light can be combined, and the way they add up or cancel is a form of arithmetic. A photonic chip uses this to multiply and add numbers as light travels through it.

One design uses a mesh of interferometers on a silicon chip. An interferometer splits a beam, changes the phase of the parts, and recombines them. A network of them can implement a matrix. Another design sends light through free space and lenses or modulators, so that a whole grid of values is processed together.

The potential benefits are low latency, because light passes through the circuit in a very short time, and low energy for the multiplication step itself. Many wavelengths of light can also travel through the same path at once.

The difficulties are real. Most photonic computing is analog. Analog means the values are continuous quantities, not exact digital numbers, so noise and drift limit precision. Light is hard to make interact with other light, so the nonlinear steps in a neural network are usually done electronically. Every value must be converted from digital to optical and back, and those conversions can consume much of the energy that was saved.

For these reasons, photonic accelerators are best viewed as early-stage devices aimed at specific workloads, usually inference. Companies working here include Lightelligence, Lumai and Q.ANT. Lightmatter began with a photonic computing chip and now also sells optical interconnect.

Moving data with light

Inside an AI data centre, thousands of chips must exchange data constantly. Copper wires lose signal quickly as speeds rise. Beyond a short distance, a copper link needs extra circuitry that uses power and adds delay. Optical fibre loses very little signal over the distances inside a data centre.

An optical link has a laser or other light source, a modulator that encodes data onto the light, a fibre or waveguide, and a photodetector that turns the light back into an electrical signal. Silicon photonics builds modulators, waveguides and detectors on silicon using chip-factory methods. Silicon is a poor light emitter, so the laser usually comes from another material, such as indium phosphide, and is often kept separate from the chip.

Today most optical links use pluggable transceivers, modules that sit at the edge of a switch. The electrical signal must still travel from the chip across the board to the module. Co-packaged optics shortens that path by placing the optical engine in the same package as the switch chip or processor. The aim is lower power per bit and higher bandwidth density.

Optical I/O goes a step further. It puts optical chiplets next to a processor so that the processor itself talks in light. Ayar Labs and Lightmatter have worked on this, and Broadcom and NVIDIA have announced co-packaged optics for network switches.

What to be sceptical about

Claims of large efficiency gains deserve a close look. Check whether the figure covers the whole system, including lasers, converters and control electronics, or only the optical core.

Check the precision. A result at four or eight bits is not comparable with a result at 16 bits.

Check the workload. A photonic chip that excels at one matrix size may not help with a full model.

For interconnect, ask about reliability. A data centre has many thousands of links, and lasers are a known source of failures. Serviceability matters as much as speed.

Why it matters

The pressure behind both ideas is the same. Moving data now costs a large share of the energy and time in AI systems, and electrical links are reaching physical limits. Light offers a way around that.

The nearer-term impact is likely to come from optical interconnect, where the technology is a replacement for an existing component. Photonic computing may find a place in particular workloads, but it has yet to show it can compete broadly with digital chips.

Companies mentioned

Company details come from the Compute Compass directory and may be out of date. This is not investment advice.